r/HonestHotTakes • u/uselessprofession • 3h ago
hot take, harshly criticise me for it! "You never cared about women's sports till it came to the question of trans women competing in it" is the worst argument I have ever heard
Every time a debate about trans women in sports against cis women, I see this idiotic line being spouted. First up, I am a fan of women's sports, I enjoy watching women's pro tennis (I in fact model my game after theirs) and women's MMA.
Most importantly, why exactly must one be a fan of women's sports to feel that trans women competing against cis women is unfair? Hormone therapy may weaken the muscles, granted, but frame size does not change if one has gone through puberty. Being an MMA fan and casual practitioner, I know that the male skeletal structure is much more capable of throwing punches with force - broader shoulders and narrower hips make for much more turning force, and thicker fists and wrists deliver force better.
Take this argument and apply it to other social issues:
"You didn't care about Ukraine till Russia invaded it"
"You didn't care about Gaza till Israel started killing"
"You didn't watch pro cycling and care about Lance Armstrong doping"
This is silly and a bad faith argument. Please do better. Spamming this line everywhere only makes one think you are more of an idiot.
Edit: reworded certain wording on the last sentence as per mod advice, thanks