I worked at a consulting/recruitment company for over 4 years and recently left. I never had a proper exit interview, but HR has now reached out to speak with me, more than two months after my last day.
I know this is not just a standard exit interview. Through former colleagues, I've learned that HR has already approached people and asked them to help build a case against my former manager. I understand they're trying to get her removed, although I don't know exactly what has been said or what stage the process is at.
For context, my experience at the company started out relatively positively, but over time, the negatives increasingly outweighed the positives. I had a difficult experience with this manager, particularly around communication, conflicting instructions, dismissive comments, and a perceived lack of recognition. I also felt there was a disconnect between management's recruiting expectations and the reality of the market, especially regarding salaries and candidates declining offers.
My concerns weren't limited to my own experience:
- I witnessed a colleague crying at work on several occasions.
- Another colleague would call me to review her emails because she was extremely anxious about writing something incorrectly or misunderstanding instructions.
- Other team members had tensions with management, and people regularly discussed leaving because of the work environment or compensation.
- One former colleague told me she felt undermined and constantly compared with others.
- I also witnessed management dominating client calls, sometimes leaving others barely any opportunity to introduce themselves.
There was also an incident where I called my manager a liar during a disagreement about information she had given a consultant. I acknowledged that my wording was inappropriate and apologized. I'm not pretending I handled every situation perfectly.
Now that I know HR is actively trying to build a case against her, I'm unsure how to approach the conversation. I do have genuine concerns about her management style and the impact it had on the team, but I don't want to feel like I'm being recruited to help get someone fired, either.
My questions are:
- Would you participate and share your honest experiences, knowing HR is trying to build a case against your former manager?
- Is there any real benefit to speaking up, or should I simply move on now that I've left?
- Would you be concerned about your testimony being attributed to you or getting back to your former manager?
- How would you approach the conversation so you can be honest and factual without appearing vindictive or as though you're trying to get her fired?
Part of me thinks HR should know what I experienced, especially given the broader issues within the team. Another part of me wonders whether there's any benefit to getting involved in a process that could become contentious, particularly when I've already moved on.
I'd appreciate honest advice, especially from people who've participated in HR investigations or given evidence about a former manager.