r/AskElectronics • u/Gamarov • 23h ago
What's actually different in my new £60 sewing pedal?
I bought a sewing machine recently and it came with a very sensitive pedal. They sell this other pedal which makes it possible to sew very slowly. £60 felt like a ridiculous price for this piece of plastic, but I'm not an electrician (I know some basics). Can someone please help me understand what the difference here is? Is it possible that I could achieve the same result by a simple modification? All I can see is the VR2 resistor missing in the new one.
UPDATE:
TL;DR: The "OLD" pedal is the same board without the VR2 trimmer. Removing VR2 from the OLD pedal gives the same 0–460 kΩ range and the same slow-speed control as the NEW one. I'm returning the new one and keeping the modified old one.
Thanks everyone for the helpful comments. I didn't expect so many!
I did some testing, and here's what I found.
Resistance measurements (VR1 range)
| Pedal | VR1 range | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| New (£60) | ~460 to 0 kΩ | No VR2 fitted |
| Old (stock) | ~400 to 0 kΩ | Turning VR2 lowered the top of the range from ~400 to ~170 kΩ. I couldn't get above 400 kΩ even with VR2 at max. |
First test: With VR2 set to its max, the old pedal was much easier to control and I could start slowly. The new pedal still felt a bit nicer, though. I put that down to the extra ~60 kΩ at the top end.
The mod: I cut VR2 off the old pedal and measured again. It now has exactly the same range as the new one (surprise, surprise). So VR2 really was the only difference between the two boards. And yes, on the NEW board they simply cut off VR2.
Result: I tested both pedals again and can't tell them apart. The modified old pedal gives me great control at very low speeds, while still being able to go full speed. I personally don't need the adjustability VR2 enabled at all.
Verdict: I'm returning the £60 pedal and keeping my modified old one.
To those who asked about the price of the old one - it came with my sewing machine (bought at Hobbycraft UK), but it's also being sold here for £47. To be fair, this shop offers you the NEW one as a free upgrade, but only when it's in stock. That's where I bought the NEW one from. Hobbycraft did not offer that upgrade, nor sells the new one.


